MY AL ALL-STAR BALLOT
Yes, yes I know I said tomorrow, you know I met next week. These baseball articles take forever and only 2 people read them lol. Remember WAR = Wins Above Replacement; a typical All-Star is worth at least 4-5 Wins, Number stated is 2 year avg. Some adjustments made for missed playing time.
Anyway here is my AL Ballot, same reasonings and standards from the NL one.
Starters
C - Joe Mauer - Minnesota Twins : 7.05 WAR
1B - Kevin Youkilis - Boston Red Sox: 5.85 WAR
2B - Dustin Pedroia - Boston Red Sox : 5.9 WAR
SS - Derek Jeter - New York Yankees : 5.35 WAR
3B - Evan Longoria - Tampa Bay Rays : 6.8 WAR
OF - Grady Sizemore - Cleveland Indians : 6.05 WAR *07-08 (Missed 2 months)
OF - Ichiro Suzuki - Seattle Mariners : 5.45 WAR
OF - Nelson Cruz - Texas Rangers : 5.4 WAR *Rookie
Pitchers
SP - Roy Halladay - Toronto Blue Jays : 8 WAR *Starter
SP - Zach Greinke - Kansas City Royals : 7.65 WAR
SP - Cliff Lee - Cleveland Indians : 7.15 WAR
SP - CC Sabathia - New York Yankees : 6.75 WAR
SP - Josh Beckett - Boston Red Sox : 6.05 WAR
SP - Justin Verlander - Detroit Tigers : 5.95 WAR
SP - Jon Lester - Boston Red Sox : 5.95 WAR
SP - Felix Hernandez - Seattle Mariners : 5.7 WAR
SP - John Danks - Chicago White Sox : 4.8 WAR
RP - Mariano Rivera - New York Yankees
RP - Jonathan Papelbon - Boston Red Sox
RP - Andrew Bailey - Oakland Athletics
RP - Joe Nathan - Minnesota Twins
Reserves
C - Victor Martinez - Cleveland Indians : 4.75 WAR
1B - Mark Teixeira - New York Yankees : 5.75 WAR
1B - Justin Morneau - Minnesota Twins : 4.75 WAR
2B - Ian Kinsler - Texas Rangers : 4.9 WAR
2B - Brian Roberts - Baltimore Orioles : 4.1 WAR
SS - Ben Zobrist - Tampa Bay Rays : 5.25 WAR (Almost entirely from this season)
SS - Marco Scutaro - Toronto Blue Jays : 4.95 WAR
3B - Alex Rodriguez - New York Yankees : 5.4 WAR
OF - Shin-Soo Choo - Cleveland Indians : 4.84 WAR
OF - Carl Crawford - Tampa Bay Rays : 4.45 WAR
OF - BJ Upton - Tampa Bay Rays : 4.25 WAR
OF - Torii Hunter - Los Angeles Angels : 4.15 WAR
Red Sox, Yankees - 5, Indians, Rays - 4, Twins - 3, Blue Jays, Mariners, Rangers - 2, Angels, Athletics, Royals, Orioles, Tigers, White Sox - 1
There you have it. Some surprises (Cruz, Choo, Bailey, Zobrist) mixed in with some future HOFers (Rivera, Rodriguez, Jeter, Halladay, Mauer). I really don’t understand how the NL loses every year, their team is much better.
Some time before Thursday night I’ll be posting the Half Way Update on the Season so keep checking back!